Bounce
By Bill Littlefield | Friday, April 23rd, 2010

If you practice, you can prevail.

But you’ll have to start early, you’ll probably have to practice for more than ten thousand hours to prevail at the highest level, and your practicing will have to be focused, precise, and probably supervised by someone who really knows what he or she is doing.

In Bounce, Matthew Syed argues that such practice is far more important than natural talent. He discusses numerous alleged naturals in fields as diverse as tennis, chess, and musical composition whose triumphs were the products of exceptional training rather than great genes.

He argues that people who succeed magnificently in business, medicine, and mathematics do so because of long, failure-riddled experience and precise, specific training. He debunks the idea that great managers can manage anybody doing anything, or that some people are simply inclined to be good at math, whereas others aren’t.

Bounce is an ambitious book, and readers may find themselves taking issue with some of the particulars. Syed argues, for example, that “it is only an expert performer…who has the capacity to choke.” What about passionate amateurs who can play Beethoven’s Fifth flawlessly in their own living rooms, but whose fingers turn into bananas when they’re asked to play for company?

Still, the book is full of provocative thinking and some conclusions very much worth entertaining, including the prescriptions against racist perceptions with which Syed concludes Bounce.

 
Tags: , , , ,      
  • Peter Merrell

    Bill,
    I enjoyed waking to your conversation with Matthew Syed and his ideas in “Bounce”. I credit an earlier author with similar concepts, W. Timothy Gallwey who wrote the “Inner Game of Tennis” in 1974. He explored the role of the conscious and the unconscious in athletic performance. Training became a way of teaching the body the proper mechanics until they became automatic and directed without conscious thought. It is experienced by any athlete at any level who performs something that they did not expect or know they were capable of: sinking the long putt, hitting the passing shot without awareness the opponent was at net, netting a half-court buzzer beater. Each task is too complex a combination of mechanical actions to consciously direct and in most cases the consciousness or awareness interferes with the actual ability perform. So, peak performance becomes an act of quieting the conscious mind to allow the unconscious to engage the muscle memory. Gallwey was an educator before his “Inner” realization. I hope that Syed message of ‘perfect practice makes perfect’ does not resurrect a conservative Horatio Alger belief that success is only a function of effort and institutional and cultural structures have no influence. If so, we risk turning our backs on a half-century of historic social progress.

  • Vic Gonzalez

    Matthew Syed’s book, “Bounce” opens up a fascinating conversation for anyone involved in teaching or playing sports. Having been both, I’ve always been interested in the ability of various atheletes to perform flawlessly under intense pressure such as bases loaded, two outs or 4-5 down, match point against. I have theorized that, practice aside, an individual’s body’s ability to produce the various endorphins, adrenalines, etc. on the spur of the moment to relax the body enough to sucessfully execute the task is at the heart of separation between “good” atheletes and “exceptional” ones. I suppose only more research on this subject will ever give us the answer.

  • Sara Solnick

    When you look around, some people resemble Gisele Bundchen and others don’t. There are visible differences that lead to different life opportunities. So it’s really hard to accept that there are no insurmountable invisible differences.

  • Don Gisselbeck

    I have known dozens of musicians and athletes who have devoted easily 10,000 hours of work to their practice, under the direction of top line teachers and using the latest techniques, yet have finally realized that they do not have what it takes to achieve greatness. Cycling alone has many such tales. Does Syed really think that people couldn’t beat Lance because they were lazy? Does he really think that if I only worked harder I could match J. S. Bach’s music? He also did not address the child prodigy problem wery well. Some of these kids haven’t been awake and understanding the world for 10,000 hours.

Major funding provided by Underwriting